Last Wednesday morning around 10:30 AM I had the chance to revisit the three CAtholic churches around Penn Station in New York. What remains are monuments to Roman Catholic decline.


Saint Michael’s on West 34th St. – closed. A message is, however, posted claiming the church will reopen soon. And we have reported on the activity of a French charismatic group here. Apparently confirming that, a seemingly recent sign has been set up outside the rectory – requesting the gates be kept shut because of a dog. However, the day after my visit, it was reported that the Archdiocese of New York had mortgaged the entire site.

(Above) Helpful advice at St. Michael’s. At least one of these churches is closed and I don’t know if many in the city would consider the parishes of Guardian Angel or Our Saviour’s as being “near” St. Michael’s.

(Above) At St. John the Baptist.
Saint John the Baptist on West 30th St– closed. The church has been “temporarily closed” since early September 2026 “for repairs.” The iron gate before the steps leading up to the entrance is padlocked. An entrance to “St. John’s Hall” on the side of the church seemed to be open but I was not inclined to investigate.
Saint Francis of Assisi on West 31st St. – partially closed. The “upper” or main church was closed, although someone was playing the organ in the dark church. I assume, though, that the upper church is still opened, at least for masses. Other parts of the parish facilities were either closed, like the outdoor “peace garden,” or seemed dilapidated. The parish is engaged in fundraising to restore its buildings via the “Fr. Mychal Judge OFM Building Fund” (which of course touches on another prominent aspect of life in this parish today). The pastor claims that the large mosaic in the upper church developed a crack after an earthquake and that repairs to this mosaic alone will cost $3,000,000. King, Maya, “How a Franciscan Priest Lives on a Vow of Poverty in Midtown Manhattan,” The New York Times (11/2/2026)
I went downstairs to the lower church which is the center of (still present, but once innumerable) Catholic devotions, confessionals and an altar on which the Blessed Sacrament is exposed. I assume (perhaps erroneously) what this parish calls the “workers’ chapel” is really that part of the lower church that has been separated by a wood and glass barrier from the section which includes the altar. About 12 people stood in line there for the one priest hearing confessions. About the same number prayed before the Blessed Sacrament. It is a substantially reduced version of what had been an exceedingly active sanctuary. According to the latest bulletin, this parish now is staffed by only three Franciscan priests. The parish of St. Francis of Assisi has survived but only at a level of activity even lower than what I described in 2014 in my initial report on this parish.










